Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

Get A Free Revenue Cycle Management Assessment

Register Now

NewBecker's 2026 Top RCM · Inc. 5000 · Dallas 100
One ASC cut aged A/R from $4.55M to $0.76M in nine months →
SOC 2 Type 2 · HIPAA · BHCOE · CASP

Get A Free Revenue Cycle Management Assessment

Register Now

Updated On:

How to Evaluate an ASC RCM Partner: 7 Factors to Compare

Author:
Christopher Helmage
ASC RCM Partner

Inside this article:

Most billing company pitches sound the same. Cleaner claims, faster payment. Nobody promises the opposite, so the promises don’t help you choose.

What helps is knowing where an ambulatory surgery center (ASC) actually loses money, and it’s rarely where the pitch says. It’s in the quirks of how ASCs get paid. A claim can clear every check on its way out the door and still come back short or denied a month later, because the second procedure in a case pays at a discount or a commercial contract carves out the implants. Or an authorization expired three days before surgery.

Here are seven things we’d check before signing with any billing company, including ours.

1. Find out if they really know ASCs

Short answer: ask if they’ve billed ASCs in your specialties. Then make them walk you through a real claim.

ASCs aren’t paid like physician offices or hospital outpatient departments. Medicare has a separate ASC payment system with a payment indicator for each procedure and its own rules for multiple procedures, and commercial payers add their own rates and authorization requirements. A company that mostly bills physician practices can be very good at claims. It can still get ASC details wrong without knowing it.

{QUOTE ON WHAT SPECIALTY-SPECIFIC GUIDELINES MUST COMPANIES CHECK BEFORE CHOOSING AN ASC RCM PARTNER}

Skip the slide listing specialties. Ask how they review coding for yours, how they hear about payer policy changes, and how they catch a documentation gap before a claim goes out.

2. Ask what happens before and after a denial

The denial rate alone really isn’t going to tell us anything. The crucial part of the denial process is why they were denied and whether the same mistake is made each time.

Denials begin before there even is a claim. The documentation isn’t right, the code didn’t match, there was no authorization, no coverage verification… All of these things have to happen before the claim can be sent out for payment.

The real test is what the company does with patterns. Say one payer keeps denying for authorization. Working each denial recovers some money but leaves the cause alone, so the same denials show up next month. A better partner keeps digging until they know whether the authorization check is broken, whether that payer changed its rules, or whether scheduling and billing aren’t talking. Then they fix that.

Good questions: what’s your initial denial rate for ASCs like ours, how do you track trends by payer and procedure, what share of denied claims do you win back, and how do you stop repeats? Then ask how each number is calculated. Two companies can report different denial rates on the same claims.

3. Check how they chase old A/R and find underpayments

A/R shows whether a billing company turns claims into cash or just into follow-up notes. The total balance hides a lot, so look at the aging buckets and which payers sit on the oldest accounts, then ask how much of it anyone expects to collect.

Good follow-up has an order to it, so a claim two weeks from a payer’s appeal deadline gets worked before a newer claim that’s moving normally; deadlines, dollar value, denial status, and the odds of recovery all decide who goes first.

Underpayments are the sneaky part. Money gets there, the claim is paid, and no one says anything. But often, billing in commercial contracts is based on the payment process, with multiples and exclusions, and there is no way to tell whether the payment is correct except by comparing it to the contract itself. Try to find out who does that comparison, how often it happens, and what the penalty is for payer underpayment.

We can name one example for sure: our work with a particular Plutus Health ASC. In nine months, we helped reduce A/R from $4.55M to $0.76M and increase collections by $2.49M.

4. Get the reporting terms in writing

You can’t check a billing company’s promises without regular reports, so settle the reporting terms before you sign. At minimum, you want to see where claims are stuck, which payers pay slowly, and whether collections track your contract rates.

HFMA’s MAP Keys give the industry standard definitions for most of the metrics worth asking about, including net days in A/R and cost to collect. These are the ones to request.

KPI What it measures
Net collection rate Share of collectible revenue actually received
Days in A/R How quickly receivables turn into cash
Initial denial rate Claims denied on first adjudication
A/R over 90 days Balances with extended aging
Cost to collect RCM operating cost relative to cash collected
Underpayment recovery Revenue recovered from payment discrepancies

Ask for results by payer, procedure, physician, and aging bucket. An overall net collection rate can look healthy while one payer quietly pays below contract.

Picture two billing companies that report the same net collection rate. One sends a monthly summary. The other shows underpayments by payer, flags denial trends, and recommends fixes. The headline number matches and the insight doesn’t.

Agree on how often reports arrive, who you call when something looks off, and when you do performance reviews.

5. Add up the real cost

The quoted rate is only part of what a billing company costs you.

Generally, fees may be calculated as a percentage of collection or a fixed monthly amount, or a combination of both. The percentage method ties their earnings to yours, so the agreement should specify which payments qualify. The fixed-amount method is simpler for budgeting, but learn what might increase the fee rate: claim volume, added services, and implementation costs.

Then read the scope. Eligibility checks, coding, denial work, A/R follow-up, payment posting, patient billing, reporting, and underpayment recovery should each be listed as in or out, and anything that’s out is either an extra charge or a job for your own staff.

6. Look past the AI pitch

Nearly every vendor mentions AI and automation these days. The real question is what process does the technology actually move the needle at? Grill on ours too.

Start with integration. The company has to work with your EHR, your practice management system, and whatever else you run. When it doesn’t, you get double entry and gaps between the clinical record and the claim.

  • Rule-based automation deals with repetitive activities such as eligibility verifications, claims validation, payment postings, and denial follow-ups.
  • AI-assisted solutions may detect denial trends, prioritize accounts, and identify payment discrepancies.
  • Agentic AI like OlympusAI takes things one step further and performs multistep processes based on predefined control mechanisms.
  • Basic software flags a denied claim for human review, whereas the advanced solution identifies denial reasons, accesses claims information, determines the next action, and routes the claim to the appropriate specialist.

The terminology isn't important in itself; what matters is whether it reduces manual effort and accelerates denial resolution. Only four questions will give you 80% of the picture:

  1. What workflows are currently automated
  2. How it integrates with your systems
  3. What improvements you achieved
  4. How you manage exceptions and risks.

Regardless of answers to these questions, there are certain decisions to be made about coding, payer disputes, documentation problems, and financial adjustments. Learn who makes these decisions and document them.

7. Take a real problem to the demo

Use the same questions with every vendor and bring one real problem from your own numbers. If your A/R over 90 days keeps growing, ask each company how they’d approach it: how they’d assess the aging, which claims they’d call recoverable, and what they’d chase first. That conversation tells you more than the polished presentation.

  1. Have you worked with ASCs in our specialties and case mix?
  2. How do you audit coding and modifier accuracy?
  3. How do you prevent recurring denials?
  4. How do you prioritize aged claims and decide what’s collectible?
  5. How do you check payments against our payer contracts?
  6. Which KPIs will we get, and how often?
  7. What connects to our EHR and practice management system?
  8. Which services does the fee include?
  9. What performance commitments and escalation steps apply?
  10. How will you handle the transition and our outstanding A/R?

And ask for paper behind the answers: written processes, sample reports, relevant case studies, and a clear split of who does what.

Know where you stand before you shop

Start with your own numbers.

  • A center with heavy denial volume probably needs tighter front-end controls.
  • One with aging receivables probably needs steadier payer follow-up and a plan to recover what’s old.

A good billing company will tell you which one you are and build around your payer mix, specialties, financial targets, and current systems.

At Plutus Health, our ASC billing uses specialty billing expertise, analytics, automation, and Olympus AI workflows for claims, denials, A/R recovery, and reimbursement oversight. We also offer a free ASC RCM assessment that looks for revenue gaps, aging A/R, denial patterns, and ways to collect more.

Get Your Free RCM Assessment

Christopher Helmage

Christopher Helmage is a seasoned Revenue Cycle Executive with over 20 years of experience in healthcare operations, revenue cycle management, and client partnership development. Throughout his career, he has built a reputation for leading with integrity, driving meaningful results, and cultivating trusted relationships with clients and teams alike. When he is not focused on advancing healthcare operations, Christopher enjoys spending time with his two children and coaching youth sports in his community.

FAQs

Experience with your specialties, accurate coding, denial prevention, steady A/R and underpayment follow-up, clear reporting, and a contract that spells out who's accountable for what. It also helps if they've handled payer mixes like yours and can connect to the systems you already use.
It depends on claim volume, collections, specialty, what's included, and how the vendor prices. Most charge a percentage of collections, a flat fee, or a mix. The most useful comparison is cost to collect, which sets total revenue cycle cost against cash collected, because the quoted rate leaves out work your own staff may still be doing.
Net collection rate, days in A/R, initial denial rate, aged receivables, cost to collect, and underpayment recovery. Together, they show whether payers pay correctly, how fast cash arrives, and what it costs to get it. HFMA's MAP Keys define several of these.
When the same denials keep coming back, aged A/R keeps growing, reports are too thin to act on, underpayments go unchallenged, or the company can't show progress against agreed targets. Start with a formal performance review. It will show whether you need a process fix, more support, or a different partner.
Yes, for tasks like claim validation, denial analysis, A/R prioritization, and spotting payment variances. How much it helps depends on how well it's set up, how it connects to your systems, and how clean your data is. Ask for measured results before you assume it will raise collections.